Harbour Club and Reef Club stand side by side on the bay side of Gulf Shore Boulevard North, and their buildings had essentially the same layout. Hurricane Ian's surge wiped out Harbour Club's first floor. Next door, Reef Club remodeled its own first floor. Harbour Club's owners left theirs empty and sold the whole 1.36-acre property for $17.5 million. Parker Borelli, whose group bought the site, told Gulfshore Business that the owners "didn't think it was worth it, so they sold."
That sale and the others on the street show something a buyer comparing older condos with new construction on the Moorings and Coquina Sands stretch of the Gulf should know. When a whole building sells to a developer, the price is for the site, and dividing it by the number of units gives the average paid per door. On this one boulevard since Ian, that average has varied by more than three times.
Five sales, priced one door at a time
The Miracle Mile is the roughly 1.3-mile stretch of Gulf Shore Boulevard North from Doctors Pass south to the Naples Beach Club. Gulfshore Business reported in its October 2026 issue that Ian's surge sped up redevelopment there. Bahama Club, Gulf Shore Colony Club, Harbour Club, Mansion House and Park Place Club have all been razed for new projects.
The per-door and per-acre figures below divide each reported sale price by the unit count or acreage reported for that site.
| Former building | Sale | Old units | Price per old door | Price per acre |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bahama Club, Gulf side | $102.6 million, 2024 | 36 | about $2.85 million | not reported |
| Executive Club, first sale | $60 million, February 2023 | 51 | about $1.18 million | about $19.5 million |
| Executive Club, resale | $92.5 million, early 2025 | 51 | about $1.81 million | about $30.1 million |
| Park Place Club, bay side | $30 million, May 2023 | not reported | not reported | about $19 million |
| Harbour Club, bay side | $17.5 million, 2025 | 21 | about $833,000 | about $12.9 million |
None of these figures come close to the typical condo price in the county. For September 2026, the Naples Area Board of Realtors reported a median closed condo price of $400,000 for Collier County excluding Marco Island, down 2.4% from September 2025. The Miracle Mile sales ran on different math. Developers were buying whole sites, and each price was set for the land and the building together.
Beach frontage set the top of the range
Bahama Club brought the highest price per door, and its sand explains most of it. Business Observer described the site at 1121 Gulf Shore Blvd. N. as a 36-unit condominium building with 200 feet of beach frontage. BH Group and The Kolter Group paid $102.6 million, financed in part by a $56.4 million loan from Centennial Bank, according to the Naples Daily News. That works out to roughly $513,000 for each foot of beach.
The new project on the site has to recover that price. Olana is planned as 12 residences of more than 10,000 square feet each, starting at $30 million, with delivery targeted for fall 2028. Divided across 12 new residences instead of 36 old ones, the land cost is about $8.55 million per new home before construction begins. The developer bought 36 doors and will sell 12, so each new door has to carry three old ones.
A few blocks south, Rosewood Residences Naples occupies more than 5 acres and nearly 500 feet of beach at 1601 Gulf Shore Blvd., where the eight two-story co-op units of Mansion House used to stand. Its 42 residences range from 4,226 to 9,673 square feet, with asking prices from $12.75 million to $45 million, and developer Anthony Solomon of The Ronto Group told Gulfshore Business the project was scheduled for completion at the end of this year. On this site the density rose. Eight old homes became 42 new ones, because the site had far more beach and acreage than the original buildings used. Our Rosewood Residences page has the current offering.
On the bay side, boat slips carried the price
Across the boulevard on the bay, there is no beach to sell, and boat slips decide the price. Lee Golub of Golub & Company told Gulfshore Business that the Park Place Club site's 11 slips with Gulf access were what drew him. He called it "the only site we found" after looking along Gulf Shore both north and south of Doctors Pass. His company paid $30 million for 1.58 acres in May 2023, eight months after Ian.
Golub also pointed to a feature of the bay side that a buyer can check on a map. "Even though we're not on the sand, nothing can be built forever on the Moorings Beach Club site," he said, referring to the land in front of his parcel. The new project, 2020 Gulf Shore, is planned as 18 units in two four-story buildings with rooftop terraces. It was in redesign when the article ran, with groundbreaking expected next spring.
Harbour Club, at 1624 Gulf Shore Blvd. N., sold at the bottom of the range, about $833,000 per old door and about $12.9 million per acre. Borelli explained the low density to Gulfshore Business: "those were '60s units, so they were a little small and they had so much land that they weren't using." Harbour House will put 14 residences on the site where 21 used to be. Each will have a private garage, a personal elevator and outdoor space with a pool and spa, and a limited number of Gulf-access boat slips will be available to buy. The land comes to about $1.25 million per new residence, a fraction of the Olana figure, because there is no beach in the price.
The Executive Club sold twice
The Executive Club sales show how much timing matters. The four-story, 51-unit building was built in 1969 at 3300 Gulf Shore Blvd. N., between Outer Doctors Bay and the Gulf. Business Observer reported that, according to Collier County property records, an LLC tied to Youngquist Brothers bought the property in February 2023 for $60 million. Kolter Urban then paid $92.5 million for the 3.07 acres in early 2025. The Gulf Shore Association of Condominiums, a nonprofit whose more than 70 member associations represent over 4,400 homes in the Moorings and Park Shore, reported the demolition in a December 2023 post titled "Adios Executive Club" and the resale in a March 2025 update.
The same land sold for about 54% more within roughly two years. Spread across the original 51 units, the 2023 sale paid about $1.18 million per door and the 2025 sale about $1.81 million. The building's owners took the earlier price.
3300 Gulf Shore will have 51 new residences in two eight-story buildings, from just under 2,000 square feet to more than 7,000 for a full-floor penthouse, along with a private 16-slip marina. Kolter Urban president Brian Van Slyke told Gulfshore Business the project had more than $60 million in hard contracts after the summer, with delivery targeted for summer 2028. In May 2025, Kolter listed anticipated starting prices of $3.7 million. With the same number of doors before and after, the land under each new residence costs about what the 2025 buyer paid per old unit, and the rest of the price pays for construction, the marina and new building systems.
Why boards are weighing the choice
Van Slyke told Gulfshore Business that the 2021 Surfside collapse and the changes to Florida law that followed have made boards of older buildings face "what it's going to take to bring these properties up to current standards," and that this "factors into the board's decision whether to make a further investment or to sell." He also said Executive Club and Bahama Club were "much older construction and kind of built right on the sand."
Not every association has decided to sell. Reef Club rebuilt its first floor. In November 2023, GSAC reported that the Naples Continental Club at 3443 Gulf Shore Blvd. N. had received purchase offers and that the association planned to restore the building. Each association weighs its own repair costs, its owners' plans and its site, so a building on the boulevard may stay standing for decades.
What the sales tell a buyer reading an older listing
The buyouts don't set a price for any unit on the market today. They do show what the market has paid for the land under a building, and which features of that land raised the price. Ask four questions about any older building on the Miracle Mile. Does it have deeded beach frontage, and how many feet? Does it have Gulf-access slips, and how many? How many units sit on how many acres? And what could be built on the site compared with what stands there now?
The answers explain most of the spread in the table. Bahama Club had the beach and a high unit count. Park Place Club had slips and an open view across the Moorings Beach Club site. Harbour Club had generous land but small 1960s units and no beach. Executive Club had water on both sides and sold at two prices because it sold at two different times.
The street around these buildings is also changing. Working with the citizen-formed Miracle Mile Committee, the City of Naples has started a conceptual streetscape design and a utilities infrastructure analysis, and the city expected to discuss the effort at a City Council workshop this fall. Construction on 3300 Gulf Shore began this year, and the three other Kolter, Borelli and Golub projects have delivery targets in 2028 or groundbreaking dates set for the coming months. For the next few seasons, an older unit on the boulevard will sit next to an active construction site.
If you are weighing an older Miracle Mile residence against new construction at 3300 Gulf Shore, Olana or Rosewood, schedule a private consultation with McCumber Group to talk through the frontage, slips and density behind the specific building you have in mind.